by Bookymummy » Mon Feb 10, 2025 5:56 pm
What a lovely, thoughtful reply.
I agree so much that telling children they are ‘so lucky’ can have completely deleterious effects. I also think it tends to make the assumption, as kinda came across from the OP, that material wealth is ‘privilege’. Whilst nice to have, I’m not convinced any material wealth is ‘privilege’ at all.
For a start, material ‘privilege’ is very relative. Your kids may well ‘have it all’ in your estimation, but there is always someone wealthier, no matter how rich you are. So maybe you’re not as ‘lucky’ as you think.
Secondly, and more importantly, the ‘wealthier echelons’ of our community including private schools, are just as prone to the social problems & angst that are often associated with ‘poverty’, such as drugs, stress, depression, eating disorders, anxiety etc. Telling a teen struggling with any of these issues that they’re ‘privileged’ because they have holidays, or a nice phone, is probably pretty pointless. Whilst on the other hand, a ‘poor’ child with a good social support network and loving, committed, capable parents may bypass all of these dramas. How ‘privileged’ is a fancy holiday in this context?
Real privilege is way more than ‘things’ and, in fact, the OPs children are ‘lucky’ in having a parent caring and loving enough to worry about such situations.
Real privilege is having a solid, reliable, capable parent, committed to doing their best for you, even if it inconveniences them. Think how many kids don’t have that, even ‘rich’ ones, even aristocratic ones, if biographies are anything to go by.
Even better, there’s the incredible privilege of having two parents who do that. Many kids including ‘rich, privileged’ ones don’t have that for many reasons. Then there’s the wider family & social support network, think how many kids don’t have any of that.
I would hazard a guess that there are quite a few ‘wealthy’ Nappy Valley kids, who would more than happily swap places with ‘less privileged’ kids if happiness, psychological security and self-worth were the metrics rather than ski holidays & mobile phones.
What a lovely, thoughtful reply.
I agree so much that telling children they are ‘so lucky’ can have completely deleterious effects. I also think it tends to make the assumption, as kinda came across from the OP, that material wealth is ‘privilege’. Whilst nice to have, I’m not convinced any material wealth is ‘privilege’ at all.
For a start, material ‘privilege’ is very relative. Your kids may well ‘have it all’ in your estimation, but there is always someone wealthier, no matter how rich you are. So maybe you’re not as ‘lucky’ as you think.
Secondly, and more importantly, the ‘wealthier echelons’ of our community including private schools, are just as prone to the social problems & angst that are often associated with ‘poverty’, such as drugs, stress, depression, eating disorders, anxiety etc. Telling a teen struggling with any of these issues that they’re ‘privileged’ because they have holidays, or a nice phone, is probably pretty pointless. Whilst on the other hand, a ‘poor’ child with a good social support network and loving, committed, capable parents may bypass all of these dramas. How ‘privileged’ is a fancy holiday in this context?
Real privilege is way more than ‘things’ and, in fact, the OPs children are ‘lucky’ in having a parent caring and loving enough to worry about such situations.
Real privilege is having a solid, reliable, capable parent, committed to doing their best for you, even if it inconveniences them. Think how many kids don’t have that, even ‘rich’ ones, even aristocratic ones, if biographies are anything to go by.
Even better, there’s the incredible privilege of having two parents who do that. Many kids including ‘rich, privileged’ ones don’t have that for many reasons. Then there’s the wider family & social support network, think how many kids don’t have any of that.
I would hazard a guess that there are quite a few ‘wealthy’ Nappy Valley kids, who would more than happily swap places with ‘less privileged’ kids if happiness, psychological security and self-worth were the metrics rather than ski holidays & mobile phones.